Stateless experiences

How NOT to react when somebody tells you they are stateless

  • 23 November 2022
  • 2 replies
  • 335 views
How NOT to react when somebody tells you they are stateless
Userlevel 5
Badge

Disclaimer: In this article, we write about how to react and not to react to the experience of stateless people. If you’re a stateless person and don’t want this kind of re-confrontation right now, feel free to skip this text and maybe come back another time. <3

 

Reading time: 5min.

Written by @Thex, Statefree Community Author 

 

With conversations about statelessness, it’s like every other topic you can think of: People react intuitively, what first comes to mind is often said immediately. With statelessness, reacting in the lightness and ease of everyday topics can often take uncomfortable turns.

“Oh, you’re stateless? That’s so cool, I also understand myself as a cosmopolitan! I wish I were stateless.”

“Stateless? I don’t get it, everybody is born somewhere.”

“Oh, stateless? I heard of it, you have a horrible life!”, ... 

Have you had that kind of conversation recently, or does it sound familiar?

Stateless people are often confronted with the broad lack of knowledge in society, encountering  disbelief, questioning and the burden of proof when sharing their story. Besides that, some people also react with the sort of sympathy and compassion that doesn’t leave room for the experiences of stateless people, their individual road of life and its richness. Assumptions are made quickly, and even though a lot of stateless people feel that statelessness has had a huge impact on their life, what defines their identity and personality differs like it does in every other individual.

While these reactions often show real feelings and are not intentionally overstepping boundaries, they also show little awareness for the harshness such conversations can mean to a stateless person.

Speaking up about a stateless person’s experience can be uncomfortable for several reasons. First and foremost, the experience of statelessness is often tied to experiences of exclusion and marginalisation. Aside from that, speaking up can also be tiring because stateless people often end up in conversations in which they must explain or prove their status or must convince the other person that their statelessness is “real”. In this case, the lack of knowledge about statelessness and its tied aspects – e.g., not having documents or specific rights – makes it harder for stateless people to just speak about their experiences and be heard and understood. It therefore needs sensibility to listen and understand what’s part of the story of being stateless.

While certain reactions might simply come from a place of confusion, lack of knowledge and awareness, there are ways to foster a compassionate conversation without creating an uncomfortable situation for stateless people. It’s time to give the conversation another turn, especially when stateless people decide to share their story and therefore are being honest and vulnerable. In respect of that, here are some hints for the next conversations to come: How not to react when somebody tells you they are stateless?

What aspects did we miss? Feel free to add your experiences in the comments and tell us how you would like others to respond to your life’s journey and its aspects of statelessness.


2 replies

“Have I listened to the experience of stateless people and am I informed about its aspects”

Yep. I heard the experience of Mike Gogulski, Thomas Jolley, Glen Lee Roberts - de jure stateless people as they renounced their US citizenship to become stateless.

I am kind-of informed of its aspects. The aspect that being stateless does not mean you’re undocumented.

And many people who claim to be stateless aren’t actually stateless, they’re just undocumented or treated poorly by their governments where the governments didn’t provide them proper documentations (but that does not make them stateless, just citizens who doesn’t have any documentations).

Yes I understood stateless as not belonging, sometimes victims to the broken citizenship paradigm and sometimes doesn’t want to have allegiance to a country.

 

I agree that statelessness isn’t well understood but the forcing citizenship onto people isn’t the solution.

Userlevel 4

hi @forcedcitizen , 

no one is planning to force citizenship onto people, you got us wrong there :) 
Our goal is to level the field and make sure that all people have access to the same starting point in life. I am sure you will agree that people that were born without a nationality often do not have the same rights or chances as people that were born with a nationality. And applying for a citizenship will most likely always be an application that actively must be filled in by the person that wants to become a citizen, so nothing forced about it :)

Reply